Cleaned manga page, can u plz rate quality.

[Shirosaki]

I need some criticism, so please tell me what quality you would give my cleaned page.
http://i100.photobucket.com/albums/m19/maanka/rate.png

[mab]

well pretty much MQ/HQ why
the gray behined sasuke is not compeletly gray it goes from light to dark
the borders seems somehow not the same :/
the detailed lines in tobi's head are gone
the karen's glasses have some detailed gone :/

but it is very good :D

[makhan]

Tobi's head has some details gone as well
and it's too small (should be 1200px height)
you used pattern for grey, right? try selecting whole gray are, fill it with grey and add noise, maybe it will look better that way

[real0st]

Very good, just dark the lines a bit by running a Burn Tool Brush on them and redo the borders. And some of Sasuke's facial lines and Tobi's details could be redraw, but not like anyone one would care, Otherwise it looks like a high quality piece of work.