FH releases critique

[makhan]

This is the thread where you can criticize FH releases. If you don't like anything about one of our releases, you can your comments here. But you can't write: "whole One Piece xxx chapter is in shitty quality". You have to tell us what exactly you don't like, e.g.: "whole One Piece xxx chapter is in shitty quality, e.g. page 01 is overburned, p02 dusty, p03 overdenoised, p04 has too dark grays, I don't know what you did to p05 but the greys are awful". You get the idea?

[Objob]

This is the thread where you can criticize FH releases. If you don't like anything about one of our releases, you can your comments here. But you can't write: "whole One Piece xxx chapter is in shitty quality". You have to tell us what exactly you don't like, e.g.: "whole One Piece xxx chapter is in shitty quality, e.g. page 01 is overburned, p02 dusty, p03 overdenoised, p04 has too dark grays, I don't know what you did to p05 but the greys are awful". You get the idea?

Every release you have is shitty all pages are low quality crap...
you guys should go back to the basics...
...
..
.
..
...
ill post some basic leveling and cleaning tutorials as soon as i can
:poke:

[makhan]

hehe, I don't agree with the low quality crap, especially since I don't like Binktopias greys, but I would gladly read some new cleaning tutorials ;)

[Doctah]

It's Objob! Is your brother Oddjob? I shopped at his store yesterday.

[B-One]

Indeed, our HQ releases are crappy too...

Wow why don't you take me as your student, I could be your bitch too.

[Doctah]

Submit your resume and wait for a reply. There's a long line though, and to be honest, I'm next so he'll probably just hire me and forget about you.

Oh, and about Binktopia's grays sucking...

FH
http://img259.imageshack.us/img259/6791/ft6507rc2.png

Bink
http://img149.imageshack.us/img149/2823/08jg5.png


I can clearly see FH's dominance...actually I can't see anything cause my screen seems to be blurry. Almost like someone took a shit on it, and obstructed my view of the pages.

[B-One]

Thank you for picking a page done by one of our recruit and not actual staff + choosing a page without actual gray.

Your jugement skills are pretty sharp eh?

[Anon]

I agree but with B, but still.... that was a bad page LOL...hope I didn't have any like that XD

[Objob]

lol did that guy just own himself?

[Anon]

No I didn't but you did in the previous post XD...and don't talk about stuff you don't understand ;)

And if you think our releases are bad the best way to improve them is to join us and show us how to do it XD

[Doctah]

So, why did you allow it to be released under your name? Releasing a page even shittier than usual is like milking a dead horse.

[B-One]

milking a horse... nice... ok made this just so you guys can understand what I'm talking about:

http://i234.photobucket.com/albums/ee200/B-One_not_a_robot/gray-black.png

here hope it's simple enough

top half = black

bottom half = grey

[Anon]

You actualy soent a min to make this LOL.... I guess you're bored out of your wits XDDDD

[B-One]

No, just wanted to contribute to our guess' knowledge amount^^

[rengwei]

XDDDDDDD
man this thread is hilarious lol...
undoubtedly, Bink's black and whites are really good but i do agree with makhan, i dont like your greys...:p
well FH does quite alot of noob stuff just because we have many noob scanlators learning...
bah what does it matter who do what better?
we're all in this shit for no money...if Bink wana claim to be the best scanlation group out there, go ahead, we're not stopping you

but Objob, you're down right a bitch for saying all our releases is shitty
if it really sucks, just dont take a look at them
this thread is for constructive comment purposes...why flame us, who are also taking out time to do this scanlation shit eh?
you're probably just a lil kid who thinks flaming us is cool...well, grow up!
it's not cool and it makes u look downright childish...and in a way it'll make Bink looks bad as well

we dont get shit for doing this, and we've released 120 releases in the past 2 months
you could at least appreciate our efforts and give some contructive comments instead...thank you

[Doctah]

XDDDDDDD
man this thread is hilarious lol...


I agree.

but Objob, you're down right a bitch

I agree again.

if it really sucks, just dont take a look at them

GENIUS!


you're probably just a lil kid who thinks flaming us is cool...well, grow up!

He'll grow up to be an arsonist...

it's not cool and it makes u look downright childish...

I agree....again.

that goes to you too Doctah

Wait what? I'm just a wandering doctah. I'm here to heal! I'm sorry, I'm gonna disagree with this one.

you could at least appreciate our efforts and give some contructive comments instead...thank you

Constructive criticism requires an appointment with me as a doctah. I'm not covered by your insurance because I'm a wandering physician.

[rengwei]

oh gomen doctah...i read wrongly...
i read "releasing a page that's shittier than milking a dead horse" lol
gomen gomen :p

[Objob]

rengwei talk to B-one and lighten up..im not just some spectator i do the same shit as you

[B-One]

Ok getting complaints of people wanting to know how this war between FH and Bink started so this is just clear some shit...

This is just some kind of stage fight... we don't have anything against MS-Bink and they don't have anything against us...well I hope ;).

Anyway, this is all to talk with our scanlating neighbours...

and here is the pm I received from objob... hope he doesn't mind^^.

Stage Fight

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote:
Originally Posted by Objob
I want you to know this is all from boredom and its kinda entertaining to see the people who take this so seriously go nuts on these boards...we're all in the same game....dont take anything i say personally besides what i PM you...and nobody in the Binktopia or Mangashare staff has any Ill-will towards FH..you guys are welcome to come in our IRC anytime.

I wish you guys luck,
Objob-(Member of Binktopia Scanlation Crew)

Haha, the same goes for me... I do visit your IRC channel and talk with you guys and personnaly I think that you're doing a great work with your scans... this is the Internet. You are also welcome to speak with us and if you do post more tutorials, we'll be more than happy to read them to get better. We are all manga fans who are doing this because we like manga... There is no reason to kill eachother XD.

~B-One^^

See, we do this because we like manga... there is no war between FH and Bink as we don't work in the same section of the manga society...

While they work on the weekly Shonens and get some kind of good quality out of it, we released more than 100 chapters in 2 month (that's an average of more than a chapter a day guys^^). We never claimed to do HQ release (except what we claim is MQ/HQ...like berserk, and HL), we somewhat tweak the raws to get them easier for the eye. By saying that they were shitty...that was a bit much tho :p.

We do aim to bring out a higher quality with the same pace... but this will be hard^^.

Anyway, hope you had some fun leechers.

hope this did clear the shit^^

[Objob]

yup its all done n shitty is just a word used on stage

[Doctah]

That post didn't clear the shit off my monitor...Still can't get it off! I blame Objob. (also kidding)

[B-One]

I blame colonel Mustard in the kitchen with the chainsaw!

[Gate]

Is the first post meant to be taken seriously?

Cause if it is, ask onemanga to either resize the script or have FH do a much better job.
I hate seeing overburned images and FH releases on OM have alot of them... >.<

[Greg]

Fake fighting on internet = failure

I mean, it's so hard to distinguish what's serious...

[kenji_37]

I think they do really fight though.... who doesnt gone mad when people say bad thing without prove even its just for a joke.... well, the thing is going calm now.... both side is accepting each other.... so that is good

[B-One]

well accepting... XD

Anyway... I think that we need to start a serious thread about this where intelligent people could post intelligent and constructive comments!

[kenji_37]

well, start with your own staff first before try to open it to public.... luckily this is nothing....... If somebody really flame us??

[B-One]

Wow this would be pretty efficient, asking the people who cleaned the pages how to clean them better... it's always easier to proofread text you didn't write, it's the same with cleaning I believe^^

[michiyohayashi]

Yeah... cos you'd have an objective view.

[makhan]

Anyway... I think that we need to start a serious thread about this where intelligent people could post intelligent and constructive comments!
what do you think I made this thread for? XD

well, start with your own staff first before try to open it to public.... luckily this is nothing....... If somebody really flame us??
I started thread like this 3 months ago. First 10 posts were either "really nice thread" or "this should be in XXX subforum". Nobody ever criticized anything XD

[Funchi]

O_o the fighting stopped? i wanted to see some blood! and limbs flying all over the place!


btw this is not an intelligent comment! plz dont take it seriously!

[Ashnagzar]

one question: is there any general FH staff critizice thread or something?XD

[makhan]

you want to criticize staff? or just our cleaning?
if cleaning, you can post here
if staff, it's more delicate matter, so you can pm one of the admins (e.g. me)

[Anon]

He's evil, he'll just use it to smirk behind other pplz backs so don't PM him XD

[Ashnagzar]

LOOOOL^^
hm who do I want to be smirked by him xD

[makhan]

no, I won't, I'm taking my job really seriously :p

[Binky]

Objob, you really are a walking /facepalm.

I had to register and prepare myself to act all conciliatory and apologetic because of you and now I find out you're just taking the piss. I'll cut you, then Funchi gets to see blood and we're all happy again. Hooray.

[B-One]

haha^^.

There is no problem with objob... he's one of his kind...but we can handle him.

But, thank you for coming all this way, I appreciate it... it's tough being an admin:p.

No hard feelings.

[Anon]

Oh,Binky is here...you should stick around a bit ;)