Applying for cleaner/typesetter

[Risentgall]

Here's my working
Kekkaishi Chapter 130 page 77 & 78

http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z232/risentgall/Kekkaishi/test/kekkai14-077.jpg
http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z232/risentgall/Kekkaishi/test/kekkai14-078.jpg

*actually i already finish scanlating chapter 130*

[makhan]

use another font, preferably Wild Words. This one isn't very good for scanlations :/
And shape text into a diamond or rectangle. And position it in the center of bubble, it should have a bit of space between the bubble border at each side.

[Risentgall]

Oh isee isee :D
Still trainee :sorry:

[mab]

ok that is ok i guess but show us cleanning for one piece or D.gray man or naruto :D

[rengwei]

yea well since this is tanko RAW maybe show us some work from magazine RAW?

typesetting has lots of room for improvement...for one, dont use all the space in the bubble....use only up to 80% of the space in the bubble...
also put in effort in centering the text...

well try again, u'll be there soon :D

[B-One]

Well, it's not that bad. That second page is better than the first one. Keep practicing, you'll be there in a jiffy^^.

[Risentgall]

This is the cleaning
From kekkaishi chapter 189

http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z232/risentgall/Kekkaishi/189_00.jpg

http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z232/risentgall/Kekkaishi/189_00_filtered2-1.jpg
http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z232/risentgall/Kekkaishi/189_00_filtered.jpg

is it good enough already ? n which one is better ?

[makhan]

1) did you resize the raw to 3000px before cleaning?
2) the pages are too small, they should be 1200px high -it's probably photobucket which resized them, upload it to imageshack.us
3) both are overdenoised OR denoised while there were too small - when you denoise you have to do that on big picture (like 3000px) and make sure the image won't be too blurry (it can be a little blurry since you won't see it after resizing to 1200px, but not too much - you have to try and see by yourself)
4) Blacks aren't completely black - you should go over them with the burn tool (make sure to not touch the greys)
5) greys look as if they were overdenoised...
6) whites are a bit underlevelled

Dunno which one is better - the first one is less blurred, but the second one has better blacks. Anyway both of them needs improvement. But it's not bad, work hard, read tutorials and clean more pages and you will improve in no time :)